| Tyler | Inner Guard | Tracing Board | Middle Chamber | Holy Spirit Watch | Seek | 3 Tour | Keystone Kraft Koncepts |

| Recently Initiated | Video and Audio Files | In Focus | The Morgan Report | F..W.. Magazine | Mailroom |

| Breaking Masonry News | Discussion Forum | Message Board | Blog | Blog | Guestbook | Books | Links |

| Pillars of the Community | Travelling Men | Ancient Landmarks | Memory Work |

| Anti-Masonry: Points of View | Craftyness | A Certain Point Within A Circle |

| Born in Blood | Catechisms of the Made Men | Fellowship |

FreePress-FreeSpeech Banner

freemasons, freemason, freemasonry

Freemasonry Watch

Expelled West Virgina Grand Master Loses Jury Trial

Had Promoted Reform Program that included Membership Visitation & Admission for Blacks, Rental of Lodge Rooms to Masonic Womens Groups

g and compass

Charleston Daily Mail

Jury finds Masons not guilty in case

Thursday December 16, 2010

by Cheryl Caswell
Daily Mail staff

A jury has determined that the Masons did not defame or damage a former Grand Worshipful Master when they threw him out of the organization.

Frank Haas, 53, of Wellsburg filed a lawsuit against the Grand Lodge in Charleston and two members of the Masons hierarchy - Charlie Montgomery and Charles Coleman. Those two men succeeded Haas as state leader of the men's brotherhood.

Haas claimed he suffered emotional distress after being unexpectedly expelled as a member in 2006, shortly after his term ended. He said other Mason leaders were unhappy that he attempted to change some of the group's restrictions on race, age and disabilities.

But after more than a week of testimony from both sides, the jury decided against Haas on all counts.

The case was presided over by Kanawha Circuit Court Judge Carrie Webster.

Haas is an attorney and administrative law judge.

He told the jury that the membership of the Masons approved his reforms, but there were allegations of fraud concerning that election. The changes ended up being overturned by Coleman.

Jack Tinney, the Charleston attorney who represented the Masonic lodge, Coleman and Montgomery, said he was pleased with the trial outcome.

"It was a complete defense victory," Tinney said. "The jury found in the defendants' favor on all counts. They awarded no damages."

The jury was asked to decide whether Haas suffered any damage due to his ouster and whether any of the three defendants placed him in a false light or intentionally inflicted emotional distress.

They decided no on all issues.

Tinney said, "They feel incredibly justified and pleased with the result. They certainly believed their actions were proper and within their province, and the jury verdict affirms that."

Whether the court had any business refereeing the decisions of a private organization was a point of contention in pre-trial arguments. Tinney asked the court to dismiss the case on that basis, but two judges - first former Circuit Judge Irene Berger and then Webster - decided to let the case go to a jury.

But the verdict sends a message that such organizations have much leeway in how they manage their affairs, make their rules and deal with membership issues.

"With regard to the future, it's a private organization that controls its own operating procedures," Tinney said. "I'm confident they will continue to do so."

Contact writer Cheryl Caswell at cher...@dailymail.com or 348-4832.

Travel to the F..W.. Middle Chamber

powered by FreeFind

Our MasonStoppers Line
Send us in confidence details of cases where you think
Organized Freemasonry has personally hurt yourself,
family, friends, aquaintances, or community. We would
also appreciate any additional background information,
links, and references on Freemasonry and the Occult.
Help us take a bite out of Freemasonry.

13,361,778 (13/02/07)
FastCounter by bCentral

Date Of Raising
June 24, 6000 A.L.

Save this site. Mirror it, if it goes 404.

X Network Banner ExchangeX Network Banner Exchange